Started reading this as an ebook, and then we found a 1970s reprint of the original serial publication in the Strand Magazine, with the original Paget illustrations. Much different reading experience. I'd already seen a number of adaptations on the screen - Cumberbatch, Brett, and Cushing, to name a few, and it was interesting to see the differences with canon.
Mostly it was just a really good read, though. I enjoyed it much more than any of the other Sherlock Holmes material I've read so far. The gothic is intense and very well done. The dying ponies! The escaped convict! The fog! The moor! The baying of the hound!
I also really enjoyed the fact that Doyle's sometimes endless exposition was largely absent by dint of Watson (the narrator) being on the scene for the vast majority of the action. Doyle's style is almost enough to overcome the exposition in most cases, but without the exposition it sparkles. I also have a theory (based on way too little data :)) that he's better with the long form than the short.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment